MSJ drafting: in development
Not available yet: LegalYoda drafts demurrers only today
The Aguilar Framework
California summary judgment practice is governed by CCP § 437c and the landmark California Supreme Court decision in Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co.(2001) 25 Cal.4th 826. The moving party's initial burden and the opposing party's burden are set out in CCP § 437c(p).
The Basic Standard
"A party may move for summary judgment in an action or proceeding if it is contended that the action has no merit or that there is no defense to the action or proceeding." — CCP § 437c(a)
Moving Party's Initial Burden
The moving party bears the initial burden of production — showing that there is no triable issue of material fact. How this burden is met depends on who is moving:
Plaintiff Moving for Summary Judgment
A plaintiff must present evidence establishing each element of each cause of action. If successful, the burden shifts to the defendant to show a triable issue.
Defendant Moving for Summary Judgment
A defendant has two options:
- Negate an element: Show that one or more elements of the plaintiff's claim cannot be established. For example, in a negligence case, show no duty existed.
- Establish an affirmative defense: Present facts establishing a complete defense (e.g., statute of limitations, release, assumption of risk).
The Separate Statement
CCP § 437c(b)(1) requires the moving party to include a "separate statement setting forth plainly and concisely all material facts which the moving party contends are undisputed." This is the heart of your motion.
Structure of the Separate Statement
Each material fact claimed to be undisputed is separately stated and numbered, and is followed by the evidence that supports it (CRC 3.1350(d)).
Opposition Separate Statement
The opposing party's separate statement responds to each numbered fact in the moving party's statement by stating whether the fact is disputed or undisputed; a response that a fact is disputed is supported by citation to evidence (CCP § 437c(b)(3); CRC 3.1350(f)). The opposition may also set out additional material facts that it contends are disputed (CRC 3.1350(f)(3)).
Evidentiary Standards
Only admissible evidence may be considered on summary judgment. This creates important requirements and opportunities:
Declarations
- Must be based on personal knowledge
- Must state facts, not conclusions
- Must be competent to testify to the matters stated
Documentary Evidence
- Must be authenticated
- Hearsay must fall within an exception
- Business records require a proper foundation declaration
Evidentiary Objections
Written objections to evidence are made in the format CRC 3.1354 requires. The court need rule only on those objections it deems material to its disposition of the motion (CCP § 437c(q)).
Triable Issues of Material Fact
Summary judgment is granted if all the papers submitted show that there is no triable issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law (CCP § 437c(c)). A dispute about a fact that is not material does not defeat the motion. Once the moving party meets its initial burden, the opposing party may not rely on the allegations or denials of its pleadings, and must set forth the specific facts showing that a triable issue of material fact exists (CCP § 437c(p)(1)-(2)).
Evidence and Inferences
The court considers all of the evidence set forth in the papers, except evidence to which objections have been sustained, and all inferences reasonably deducible from it, except that summary judgment is not granted based on inferences contradicted by other inferences or evidence that raise a triable issue as to a material fact (CCP § 437c(c)).
Summary Adjudication
Under CCP § 437c(f), a party can move for summary adjudication of:
- One or more causes of action
- One or more affirmative defenses
- One or more claims for damages
- One or more issues of duty
A motion for summary adjudication is granted only if it completely disposes of a cause of action, an affirmative defense, a claim for damages, or an issue of duty (CCP § 437c(f)(1)).
Timing
Notice Period
Since January 1, 2025 (AB 2049), the notice of motion and supporting papers must be served at least 81 days before the hearing (CCP § 437c(a)(2)). If served by mail, add 5 calendar days for an address within California, 10 days outside California but within the United States, and 20 days outside the United States. Fax, express mail, or overnight delivery adds 2 court days; electronic service adds 2 court days (CCP § 1010.6). The motion must be heard no later than 30 days before trial (CCP § 437c(a)(3)).
Opposition
Opposition is due 20 days before the hearing (CCP § 437c(b)(2)).
Reply
Reply is due 11 days before the hearing (CCP § 437c(b)(4)).
Continuances Under CCP § 437c(h)
If it appears from affidavits submitted in opposition that facts essential to justify opposition may exist but cannot, for reasons stated, then be presented, the court shall deny the motion or order a continuance to permit affidavits to be obtained or discovery to be had (CCP § 437c(h)).
Points to Check
The Separate Statement
The papers in support of the motion must include a separate statement of the material facts claimed to be undisputed (CCP § 437c(b)(1)). Failure to comply with this requirement may in the court's discretion constitute a sufficient ground for denying the motion (CCP § 437c(b)(1)).
Evidence Considered
The court considers all of the evidence set forth in the papers except evidence to which objections have been made and sustained (CCP § 437c(c)).
MSJ drafting is in development
LegalYoda drafts California demurrers today, for pilot users. Other motion types are in development.
Request pilot accessDocument preparation service. Not a law firm. Not legal advice.