Skip to main content
Civil Litigation6 min readBy LegalYoda editorial |

CCP 430.10(g): Written, Oral or Implied

Four-step card for CCP 430.10(g): the written, oral or implied contract ground, the CCP 430.30 rule, the CCP 430.41 meet and confer, and the CCP 430.40 time to demur.

Subdivision (g) of CCP § 430.10 is the contract-specific ground: in an action founded upon a contract, it cannot be ascertained from the pleading whether the contract is written, is oral, or is implied by conduct. This article sets out the cached text, the parallel provision for answers in CCP § 430.20(c), and how CCP § 430.30, CCP § 430.41 and CCP § 430.40 apply. It does not say what makes a contract written, oral or implied, or why the classification matters. Those points are outside the cache and have to be verified.

CCP § 430.10(g): what the subdivision says

CCP § 430.10 allows the party against whom a complaint or cross-complaint has been filed to object, by demurrer or answer as provided in CCP § 430.30, to the pleading on any one or more of the listed grounds. Subdivision (g) reads: in an action founded upon a contract, it cannot be ascertained from the pleading whether the contract is written, is oral, or is implied by conduct.

The ground has a threshold and a test. The threshold is an action founded upon a contract. The test is whether a reader can ascertain from the pleading which of three kinds of contract is alleged. It is not a general attack on the sufficiency of a contract claim; that is subdivision (e).

The parallel provision for an answer

CCP § 430.20(c) allows a demurrer to an answer where the answer pleads a contract and it cannot be ascertained from the answer whether the contract is written or oral. The answer version has two categories, written or oral, where the complaint version has three, adding implied by conduct. The text does not explain the difference, and a paragraph aimed at an answer should quote subdivision (c) of CCP § 430.20, not subdivision (g) of CCP § 430.10.

What the text does not say

The cache has no provision that says how a contract must be pleaded to make its kind ascertainable, and none that says why the kind matters. This article does not state those rules. The existing article on demurring to a breach of contract claim covers the contract-related provisions that are cached, and CCP § 425.10(a)(1) supplies the general pleading standard: a statement of the facts constituting the cause of action in ordinary and concise language.

Subdivision (g) is separate from subdivision (f), which is aimed at a pleading that is ambiguous or unintelligible generally. A complaint can be perfectly clear about the parties and the breach and still not say whether the agreement was signed, spoken or inferred. CRC 3.1320(a) requires each ground to be in a separate paragraph, so the two have to be written separately and the (g) paragraph should be tied to the contract allegations.

CCP § 430.30 and the face of the complaint

The ground is defined by what can be ascertained from the pleading, which makes it a face-of-the-pleading ground by its own words. CCP § 430.30(a) allows a demurrer when a ground appears on the face of the pleading or from a matter the court is required to or may take judicial notice. CCP § 430.30(b) provides that a ground that does not appear on the face of a complaint or cross-complaint may be taken by answer, and CCP § 430.30(c) allows a demurrer and an answer at the same time.

In practice, the paragraph needs to show that the complaint alleges a contract but is silent or equivocal on the three categories. If the complaint attaches or quotes a document, the face of the pleading may answer the question and the ground may fall away.

General or special: a practice label to verify

Practitioners commonly call subdivision (g) a special demurrer ground. That is practice and case law, not the cached text of CCP § 430.10, and it should be verified. CRC 3.1113(a) is the cached rule that mentions a special demurrer, treating a missing memorandum as an admission that the motion or special demurrer is not meritorious and, for a demurrer, as a waiver of all grounds not supported. CCP § 92(c) states that special demurrers are not allowed; confirm in the current code which cases it governs.

Meet and confer under CCP § 430.41

CCP § 430.41(a) requires the meet and confer in person, by telephone or by video conference before filing, and CCP § 430.41(a)(1) requires the demurring party to identify the specific causes of action subject to demurrer and the legal support for the deficiency. For this ground, the letter can say which cause of action is founded on a contract and ask which kind of contract is alleged. The other side must provide legal support that the pleading is sufficient or explain how it could be amended to cure the problem.

An amendment that states the kind of contract would answer the objection on its face, which is a reason to raise it in the conference. CCP § 430.41(b) bars a demurrer to a pleading amended after a demurrer was sustained on grounds that could have been raised against the earlier version, so the point is best made once. CCP § 430.41(d)(2) excludes unlawful detainer proceedings from the section.

Timing under CCP § 430.40

CCP § 430.40(a) allows a demurrer to a complaint or cross-complaint within 30 days after service. CCP § 430.41(a)(2) requires the meet and confer at least 5 days before the responsive pleading is due and gives an automatic 30-day extension, by a declaration under penalty of perjury filed and served on or before the date a demurrer would be due, when the parties cannot meet in time. For an answer that pleads a contract, CCP § 430.40(b) gives a party who filed a complaint or cross-complaint 10 days after service of the answer.

CCP § 430.50 allows a demurrer to the whole pleading or to any cause of action. A subdivision (g) paragraph is written against the contract cause of action or actions, and CRC 3.1320(a) requires it to say so.

Checklist

Items to confirm in the current code before a subdivision (g) paragraph is filed:

  • That the cause of action is founded upon a contract, and which paragraphs allege it.
  • That the complaint, with any attached or quoted document, does not show whether the contract is written, oral or implied by conduct.
  • Authority, outside the cache, for why the classification matters in the case.
  • Whether the target is a complaint or cross-complaint (CCP § 430.10(g)) or an answer (CCP § 430.20(c)).
  • The meet and confer record and declaration (CCP § 430.41(a)(1), (a)(3)).
  • The separate paragraph and its target (CRC 3.1320(a)).

Authorities referenced

  • CCP § 430.10: Subdivision (g): action founded upon a contract; written, oral or implied by conduct cannot be ascertained.
  • CCP § 430.20: Subdivision (c): the answer-side ground, written or oral.
  • CCP § 430.30: Subdivisions (a) through (c): face of the pleading, judicial notice, answer and demurrer together.
  • CCP § 430.40: Subdivisions (a) and (b): 30 days to demur to a complaint or cross-complaint; 10 days to demur to an answer.
  • CCP § 430.41: Subdivisions (a), (b) and (d): meet and confer, later-demurrer bar and exclusions.
  • CCP § 430.50: Demurrer to the whole pleading, to any cause of action, or to any defense.
  • CCP § 425.10: Subdivision (a)(1): statement of facts in ordinary and concise language.
  • CCP § 92: Subdivision (c): special demurrers not allowed; confirm which cases the section governs.
  • CRC 3.1320: Subdivision (a): each ground in a separate paragraph stating its target.
  • CRC 3.1113: Subdivision (a): supporting memorandum and the effect of omitting it.

Reference only. Not legal advice. LegalYoda is a document preparation service, not a law firm.